Broadway Pizza (Cleveland Ohio)

Broadway Pizza in Cleveland, Ohio, stands out as a beloved local hotspot for pizza takeaway and meal delivery, delivering authentic Italian-American flavors with a comforting, old-school vibe. Nestled on Broadway Avenue, this neighborhood gem offers an expansive menu that goes far beyond your typical slice, satisfying cravings for everything from hearty pizzas to classic Italian dinners.

At the heart of Broadway Pizza’s appeal is its dedication to fresh, quality ingredients and generous portions. The signature Stromboli is a customer favorite — a large, hand-flattened dough layered with savory pepperoni, ham, and zesty banana peppers, then rolled tightly with cheese and served with rich garlic butter and two sides of sauce. It’s a mouthwatering treat that provides a perfect balance of flavors and textures, embodying the warmth and soul of Italian comfort food.

For pizza lovers, the variety is impressive: from the indulgent Meat Lovers and the flavorful Extra Sausage and Pepperoni with Garlic Butter Crust "OH MY" to the lighter but equally satisfying Greek Salad and Chef’s Salad. The crust is consistently crispy yet soft enough to complement the copious mozzarella cheese and perfectly seasoned toppings. Wings enthusiasts won’t be disappointed either — the Garlic Parmesan Chicken Wings and an array of dipping sauces like Mango Habanero or Kickin' Bourbon elevate the experience with bold, nuanced flavors.

Broadway Pizza’s dessert selections deserve a special mention. Rich and creamy indulgences like the Chocolate Mousse Cheesecake, Caramel Apple Cheesecake, and delicate Mini Cannoli offer a sweet finish that rounds out any meal beautifully.

The atmosphere here feels welcoming and genuine. Reviewers often praise the friendly, attentive staff who make every visit memorable. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick, satisfying slice or ordering in the early hours (they’re famously open late, delivering even at 1 AM on Sundays), the service impresses with its warmth and efficiency. Locals like Steve B call it their “go to place” for its consistently fantastic pizza and superb customer care. Karletta Dingess highlights the late-night hours and comprehensive menu, while Noa shares a heartfelt experience of how the team went above and beyond during a late-night order, bringing joy to the whole family.

If you’re in Cleveland and craving pizza or Italian classics made with care and served with a smile, Broadway Pizza is an essential stop. With its delicious, hearty dishes, generous portions, and genuine hospitality, it’s more than just a takeaway spot — it’s a place where food feels like home.